Linguistic Camouflage in Totalitarianism: Ismail Kadare’s Resistance through Literature

Authors

  • ilir shyta
  • Eris Rusi

    Department of Language and Literature, University “Fan S. Noli”, Korça 7001, Albania

  • Jonela Spaho

    Department of Language and Literature, University “Fan S. Noli”, Korça 7001, Albania

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.30564/fls.v7i2.8272
Received: 30 November 2024 | Revised: 11 January 2025 | Accepted: 14 January 2025 | Published Online: 18 February 2025

Abstract

Ismail Kadare holds an important position in contemporary literature, maintaining significant influence across Albanian and global literary landscapes. During the latter half of the twentieth century, Kadare faced the oppressive constraints of socialist realism imposed by the totalitarian communist regime in Albania. To survive under this regime, he employed a perilous strategy known as the "Pact with the Devil" (Pactum Cum Diabolus). This approach entailed a dual mechanism: on one hand, Kadare conformed to the dictatorial system's ideological demands in certain aspects of his work, thereby ensuring his survival and continued publication. On the other hand, he crafted anti-system literature that subtly resisted and undermined Socialist Realism. By situating his narratives in historical settings such as the Turkish empire, ancient Egypt, or Greece, Kadare crafts a metaphorical dialogue that transcends the immediate temporal and political constraints of his era. His strategic use of linguistic tools, including symbolic imagery, rhetorical questions, and allusions, enables him to encode resistance within his narratives. The "Pact with the Devil" thus serves as a linguistic camouflage, allowing Kadare to evade the constraints of communist propaganda and ideology, which sought to suppress intellectual freedom and creativity. The "Pact with the Devil" serves as a literary camouflage, enabling Kadare to evade communist propaganda and ideology, which sought to suppress free expression and talented intellectuals within the country. Through this nuanced strategy, Kadare's literature becomes a form of camouflaged resistance against totalitarian oppression.

Keywords:

Ismail Kadare; Linguistic Camouflage; Literary Resistance; S Metaphorical Dialogue; Historical Settings; Linguistic Strategies; Subversive Language; Censorship

References

[1] Spasse, S., 2013. Why? 1935. Edlora: Tirana, Albania.

[2] Rusi, E., 2023. When the world was asleep – Vilson Blloshmi and Genc Leka, literary works. Edualba: Tirana. Albania. p. 55.

[3] Rusi, E., 2023. The fantastic as a literary paradigm in 20th-century Albanian literature – A monographic study. Academy of Sciences of Albania: Tirana, Albania. pp. 46, 218–219.

[4] Kassabova, K., 2021. Surviving and subverting the totalitarian state: A tribute to Ismail Kadare [Internet]. World Literature Today. Available from: https://www.worldliteraturetoday.org/2021/winter/surviving-and-subverting-totalitarian-state-tribute-ismail-kadare-kapka-kassabova (cited 11 January 2025).

[5] Durand, C., 2010. Preface in: Kadare I. Agamemnon's Daughter. Onufri: Tirana, Albania. pp. 3–9.

[6] Morgan, P., 2010. Ismail Kadare, The Writer and the Dictatorship 1957--1990. Routledge: New York, NY, USA.

[7] Damrosch, D., 2003. What is World Literature? Princeton University Press: Princeton, NJ, USA. p. 5.

[8] Bellos, D., 2005. The Englishing of Kadare: Notes of a Retranslator. The Complete Review. 6(2).

[9] Arendt, H., 1958. The Origins of Totalitarianism. The World Publishing Company: Cleveland, OH, USA.

[10] Kadare, I., 1978. "The Festival Committee." in: The Three-Arched Bridge. Naim Frashëri: Tirana, Albania. p. 323.

[11] Kadare, I., 2009. The Burden of the Cross. Works XX. Onufri: Tirana, Albania. pp. 224–225.

[12] Kadare, I, 2014. In: Cedrone, G., Maksuti, L. (Eds.). The dictatorship feared Dante, the gulags were like the Inferno. Kadare talks about Albania between past and future. La Repubblica.Kadare, I., 2012. The castle. Onufri: Tirana, Albania. p. 195.

[13] Kadare, I., 1969. The castle. Naim Frashëri: Tirana, Albania. p. 8.

[14] Bosquet, A., 1995. Kadare: the European writer. Fayard: Paris, France.

[15] Kundera, M., 1988. The Art of the Novel. Harper & Row: New York, NY, USA.

[16] Kadare, I., 1990. Invitation to the Studio. Onufri: Tirana, Albania.

[17] Kokobobo, A., 2021. Ismail Kadare and the Worldliness of Albanian Literature. World Literature Today. Available from: https://www.worldliteraturetoday.org/2021/winter/ismail-kadare-and-worldliness-albanian-literature-ani-kokobobo (cited 11 January 2025).

[18] Apolloni, A., 2012. Proteus Paradigm. OM: Prishtina, Kosovo.

[19] Kadare, I., 1963. The General of the Dead Army. Onufri: Tirana, Albania.

[20] Canosinaj, V., 2013. Magical Realism in Albanian Literature. Naim Frashëri: Tirana, Albania.

[21] Rusi, E., 2022. Fantastic Literature against Propaganda in Ismail Kadare’s Novels. Analele Universității din Craiova. Seria Științe Filologice. Limbi Străine Aplicate. (1), 205–218. DOI: https://doi.org/10.52744/AUCSFLSA.2022.01.21

[22] Alia, R., 1980. Improving quality: a fundamental duty of literature and the arts. Nëntori. 4, 19–20.

[23] Kadare, I., 1981. Completing the picture of the socialist era: a duty of our literature and arts. Nëntori. (5), 100.

[24] Faye, É., 2011. Preface 1. in: Kadare, I. (Ed.). The Successor. Onufri: Tirana, Albania. pp. 3–11.

[25] Kadare, I., 2011. The great winter. Onufri: Tirana, Albania. p. 141.

[26] Etiemble, R., 1988. Openings to a global comparatism. Ch. Bourgois

[27] Rusi E.,2023 Beyond linguistic boundaries in the novels of Luan Starova. In Book of proceedings. Twenty-sixth international conference on: “Social and Natural Sciences – global challenge 2023” (ICSNS XXVI-2023). Berlin, Germany. p. 77.

Downloads

How to Cite

shyta, ilir, Rusi, E., & Spaho, J. (2025). Linguistic Camouflage in Totalitarianism: Ismail Kadare’s Resistance through Literature. Forum for Linguistic Studies, 7(2), 654–667. https://doi.org/10.30564/fls.v7i2.8272